ISIS Video Appears to Show Executions of Ethiopian Christians in Libya

ISIS Video Appears to Show Executions of Ethiopian Christians in Libya

An image from a video shows masked militants in a desert in Libya ready to execute men said to be Ethiopian Christians.

CAIRO — The Islamic State released a video on Sunday that appears to show fighters from its branches in southern and eastern Libya executing dozens of Ethiopian Christians, some by beheading and others by shooting.

Prefaced by extensive speeches and interviews that appear to take place in the Islamic State’s strongholds in Syria and Iraq, the video of the killings, if confirmed, would be the first evidence that the group’s leaders in those countries are coordinating with fighters under the group’s banner in those parts of Libya, compounding fears of its expansion across the Mediterranean.
The Islamic State, also known as ISIS or ISIL, released a video in February that appeared to show masked fighters in its western Libyan branch, the so-called Tripolitania Province of the Islamic State, beheading a group of Egyptian Christians who had been abducted in the city of Surt. The group has now established control of Surt, and its fighters there are sporadically battling militia troops from the nearby city of Misurata.
The video released on Sunday appears to show Islamic State fighters in what the group calls its “Fezzan Province,” in the south, and its “Barqa Province,” in the east, carrying out executions according to the group’s trademark rituals.
Militants in Egypt, Algeria, Afghanistan, Nigeria and elsewhere have pledged loyalty to the Islamic State and its self-declared caliphate, but Libya is the first country outside the group’s territory in Syria and Iraq where its core leadership has demonstrated practical communication and collaboration with its far-flung “provinces.”
If more confirmation of its authenticity emerges, the video will upend both Western and Libyan views of the Islamic State’s presence in the country. Fighters in the three regions of Libya had previously claimed responsibility for various acts of violence carried out in the Islamic State’s name, but most analysts presumed that most of those fighters, at least the ones outside Surt, were operating independently and using the name to capitalize on the group’s fearsome reputation.
Now fighters in all three provinces appear connected enough to the core group’s leadership that they were able to coordinate separate, mass executions, film them and send the video back to Syria or Iraq for production and release.

The Evolution of ISIS

How has ISIS, a 21st-century terrorist organization with a retrograde religious philosophy, spread from Iraq to Syria, Libya and beyond?

MUSIC <SOT: OBAMA> “ISIS is a terrorist organization.” ISIS, ISIL, I-S, DAESH —- THESE NAMES ALL REFER TO THE SAME MILITANT GROUP — THE ISLAMIC STATE. CALL THEM WHAT YOU WANT, BUT BY SUMMER 2014, THEY WERE KNOWN WORLDWIDE. SOT: OBAMA: “These terrorists are desperate for legitimacy ... especially their attempt to use Islam to justify their violence.” MUSIC HEADLINE: The Story of ISIS Nats of ISIS THEY DEFY THE STEREOTYPE OF SCATTERED TERRORISTS HIDING IN CAVES. PARTS OF ISIS ARE ORGANIZED LIKE A LIGHT ARMY, OTHERS AS SOPHISTICATED TERRORIST CELLS. IT’S ALL AIMED TOWARDS ONE GOAL: TO REDRAW THE MAP OF THE MIDDLE EAST BY CREATING A NEW STATE — AN ISLAMIC STATE. <SOT of jihadist> “We will break the barrier of Iraq, Jordan, Lebanon, all the countries.” SO HOW DID THIS ACTUALLY HAPPEN? HOW DID A TERRORIST ORGANIZATION END UP IN CONTROL OF MASSIVE AMOUNTS OF TERRITORY ACROSS SYRIA AND IRAQ? THIS - IS THE STORY OF ISIS. HOW THEY BUILT A 21ST-CENTURY TERRORIST ORGANIZATION, MADE IT SELF-FINANCING, AND HOW THEY ARE NOW EVOLVING UNDER A NEW SET OF CHALLENGES. MUSIC CHANGE TO MARK TRANSITION ISIS EMERGED IN PART FROM THE ASHES OF AL QAEDA IN IRAQ. ITS LEADER IS ABU BAKR AL-BAGHDADI, AN IRAQI PREACHER WHO FOUGHT IN THE INSURGENCY. IN 2004, HE WAS CAPTURED BY THE U-S BUT WAS CONSIDERED INSIGNIFICANT ENOUGH THAT THEY RELEASED HIM. Nats of Baghdadi appearance BAGHDADI LED HIS GROUP TO SYRIA WHERE THEY ESTABLISHED A STRONGHOLD. AMID THE CHAOS OF THE CIVIL WAR — ISIS SOON BECAME THE MOST POWERFUL TERRORIST FACTION. NAT OF ISIS patrolling Raqqa THE SYRIAN CITY OF RAQQA BECAME THE GROUP’S CAPITAL BY MID-2013. THERE, THEY INSTITUTED REAL GOVERNANCE: ESTABLISHING SHARIAH COURTS, TAKING OVER ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDINGS, EVEN PUTTING UP STREET SIGNS. NAT OF ISIS patrolling Raqqa - directing traffic or whatnot TO SUPPORT THIS GROWING INFRASTRUCTURE, THEY FOCUS ON FINANCES: TAKING CONTROL OF OIL RESOURCES AND BECOMING SYSTEMATIC KIDNAPPERS. THEY HAVE SECURED MULTI-MILLION DOLLAR RANSOMS FROM MANY WESTERN COUNTRIES. ON THE BATTLEGROUND, THEY ARE MORE PROFESSIONALIZED THAN MOST OF THEIR COMPETITORS. ISIS’S RANKS INCLUDED MANY OFFICERS - AS WELL AS SOLDIERS - FROM SADDAM HUSSEIN’S ARMY WHO DRAW ON DECADES OF MILITARY EXPERIENCE. Nats of drones ANOTHER DISTINCTIVE ADVANTAGE IS HOW ISIS USES TECHNOLOGY TO WOO FIGHTERS FROM ALL OVER THE WORLD - AND IN MANY LANGUAGES. RECRUITMENT VIDEO IN ENGLISH THEY ARE STRATEGIC ONLINE, USING FACEBOOK, TWITTER AND YOUTUBE. THEY RELEASED VIDEOS FEATURING A CAPTURED BRITISH JOURNALIST HOSTING SLICKLY-PRODUCED “TALKS” TRYING TO CONVINCE WESTERN AUDIENCES ON THE MERITS OF JIHAD. Sot from Cantlie tapes “Over the next few programs, I’m going to show you the truth.” THIS KIND OF PROPAGANDA IS WORKING. ISIS NOW BOASTS ABOUT 3,000 FOREIGN FIGHTERS FROM 80 COUNTRIES <SOT: ISIS canadian from video - “I was like any other regular Canadian. I watched hockey.” MUSIC TRANSITION NATS OF BIG EXPLOSION FROM THE FIGHTING IN MOSUL UPON THEIR RETURN TO IRAQ IN JUNE 2014, THEIR FIRST MAJOR MILITARY VICTORY WAS THE FALL OF THE COUNTRY’S 2ND LARGEST CITY — MOSUL. IT SHOCKED THE WORLD. SOT: From Reuters, Arabic, (Arabic) MAN FLEEING FROM MOSUL, NIBHAN JASSIM, SAYING: “People are in the streets, and people are lying dead on the streets. THEN THE MILITANTS QUICKLY SEIZED MORE IRAQI TOWNS, ENCROACHING ON BAGHDAD. Soundbite from Baghdad resident “The security situation is deteriorating.” A SECOND HIGH-PROFILE MOMENT WAS THE FORCIBLE EXPULSION OF THE YAZIDIS — A RELIGIOUS MINORITY IN IRAQ. SOME WERE KILLED AND MORE THAN 30,000 WERE FORCED TO FLEE INTO THE MOUNTAINS. SOUNDBITE (English) Will Parks, UNICEF Chief Field Officer: “50-thousand people we estimate, are stuck in the mountains at this time ... [BUTT SOTS] They’re sleeping out in the open, they’ve got no food, no water, no medical supplies.” ANOTHER KEY TO THEIR EXPANSION IS SHEER BRUTALITY. THERE ARE THE MASS EXECUTIONS AND UNMARKED GRAVES OF MOSTLY FELLOW MUSLIMS. MANY REPORTS OF RAPE AND OF WOMEN BEING SOLD ALSO CONTINUE TO SURFACE. NATS FROM “SLAVE MARKET DAY” selling of Yazidi girls ISIS’S BRUTAL TACTICS - WITH REGULAR BEHEADINGS AND THE KILLINGS OF CIVILIANS - WAS EVEN CRITICIZED BY AL-QAEDA’S LEADERSHIP, WHICH FORMALLY SEVERED TIES IN FEBRUARY 2014. MUSIC CHANGE TO SIGNAL TRANSITION Natpop of us airstrikes BUT SINCE AUGUST 2014, RESISTANCE TO ISIS GREW. FIRST, THEY WERE DEALT A SIGNIFICANT BLOW ONLINE. NATS OF ISIS ON YOUTUBE SOCIAL MEDIA SITES — NOW MORE ADEPT AT SPOTTING ISIS’S VIDEOS — TAKE THEM DOWN ALMOST IMMEDIATELY. Nats of missiles launching SECOND, ON THE MILITARY FRONT, AN INTERNATIONAL AIRSTRIKE CAMPAIGN HAS SLOWED THE GROUP’S ADVANCE. SOT FROM OBAMA ON AIRSTRIKES. 4:45 “American forces will lead a broad coalition to roll back this terrorist threat.” PRESIDENT OBAMA DEPLOYED MORE NON-COMBAT TROOPS TO IRAQ IN EARLY NOVEMBER. Nats of missile strikes AND IN SYRIA - WHERE THE HEADQUARTERS REMAIN - AIRSTRIKES HAVE DESTROYED MANY OIL REFINERIES. NOW, INSTEAD OF STORMING INTO TOWNS WITH A SHOW OF BRAVADO, ISIS FIGHTERS MOVE IN SMALL GROUPS AND RELY ON SLEEPER CELLS. NATS OF Iraqi tribes FINALLY, A TURNING POINT CAME FROM SOME LOCAL TRIBES, VILLAGERS AND IRAQI TROOPS- WHO ARE BANDING TOGETHER TO PUSH THE GROUP BACK. NATS OF FIGHTING ISIS’S MOMENTUM HAS STALLED SIGNIFICANTLY SINCE LAST SUMMER, BUT THEY REMAIN IN CONTROL OF LARGE SWATHS OF TERRITORY. THEY’VE KEPT THE WORLD’S ATTENTION LARGELY THROUGH A STEADY STREAM OF INCREASINGLY SHOCKING VIDEOS AS WELL AS INSPIRING VIOLENCE WORLDWIDE. <SOT: Coulibady> “You attack the Islamic state, we are attacking you.” BUT NOW — UNDER SO MUCH CONTINUED PRESSURE — THE QUESTION IS, HOW WILL ISIS CONTINUE TO EVOLVE? ENDIT



How has ISIS, a 21st-century terrorist organization with a retrograde religious philosophy, spread from Iraq to Syria, Libya and beyond?

During the last five minutes of the half-hour video, the video cuts back and forth between scenes in the southern desert and a beach along the coast, at one point displaying both with a split screen. Both were filmed with the same sophisticated camera angles and editing that have distinguished other Islamic State films from indigenous Libyan videos.

Masked fighters lead a row of bound captives dressed in black into the desert and then shoot each of the prisoners in the back of the head. Another group of masked fighters leads a row of prisoners in orange jumpsuits along a beach and then beheads each of them with a long knife. The video shows fighters placing the severed heads on the bodies lying on the sand as bloody surf washes over them.
“You will not have safety, even in your dreams, until you accept Islam,” declares a masked figure, speaking English with an American accent and pointing a revolver at the camera. “To the nation of the cross: We are back again.”
Of all the places the militants have used the group’s name, Libya may also be uniquely vulnerable to penetration because of the collapse of any central authority since the overthrow of Col. Muammar el-Qaddafi four years ago.
Over the last nine months, its feuding militias and city-states have split into two main warring factions — one controls the capital, Tripoli, and the other, including the internationally recognized government, has fled to the eastern cities of Tobruk and Bayda. Both factions have so far appeared more intent on fighting each other than uniting to stop the Islamic State’s expansion.
In addition, Libyan banks and homes still hold significant wealth. Vast oil deposits wait below ground, and the country’s long Mediterranean coast is a useful departure point to destinations in Europe or around the region.
A spokesman for the Ethiopian government said Sunday that it could not confirm if those killed in the video were its citizens, according to news reports. Many African migrants come to oil-rich Libya seeking jobs or passage to Europe.
Some of the Egyptian Christians killed by the Islamic State in western Libya were recognized in the earlier video by their families in Egypt as relatives who had been abducted in Surt, helping confirm that video’s authenticity. Those killings prompted a retaliatory air raid by Egypt on targets in Derna, Libya, an Islamist stronghold where the Islamic State’s “Barqa Province” is believed to be based.

A video released on Sunday by the Islamic State appears to show fighters from affiliates in southern and eastern Libya executing dozens of Ethiopian Christians.

Both Libyan Islamic State videos were released by the Al Furqan media group, which is controlled by the Islamic State’s leadership and often distributes its propaganda. The video released Sunday begins with about 25 minutes of scenes that appeared to have been filmed in Syria and Iraq. After reviewing the portrayal of Jesus in the Quran, a narrator briefly walks through the history of the emergence of Catholicism, Eastern Orthodoxy and Protestantism.
The video intersperses what appear to be scenes from a costume drama depicting rows of medieval Muslim soldiers marching with spears, fighting with bows and arrows, and assaulting a castle. Then it cuts briefly to images of the Islamic State’s leader, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, climbing the steps to the minbar, or pulpit, of the Mosul mosque where he proclaimed himself caliph.
A narrator, identified as Sheikh Abu Malik Anas al-Nashwan, says in formal Arabic that the Islamic State requires Christians living under its dominion to convert to Islam or pay jizya — the tax levied on non-Muslims living under Muslim rule in the Middle Ages. He speaks against a backdrop of lush foliage that looks more like northern Syria than anywhere in Libya, and the video shows a building and van used by the Islamic State to handle such payments in a town in the Syrian province of Aleppo.
The narrator repeatedly uses a derogatory term for Christians that is something like calling them Nazarenes. Yet much of the video is devoted to testimonials from people speaking Arabic with Syrian or perhaps Iraqi accents who say they are Christians living happily under the Islamic State in Aleppo, Raqqa and elsewhere. All say that they live freely after paying the tax; it is impossible to know how much coercion they may have felt at the time.
At one point, the video includes a scene of what appear to be two Islamic State fighters lecturing a schoolroom full of adult Christians on the virtues of Islam. A rifle leans against the wall behind them.
For those who refuse to convert or pay the tax, the narrator promises death and destruction, and scenes of Islamic State fighters desecrating the churches of Mosul illustrate the threat. “The Christians in Mosul have chosen their own destiny,” the narrator warns.
The video then moves to what the narrator describes as areas of Libya under the Islamic State’s rule. A short scene depicts what appear to be African migrants converting to Islam and then being hugged by Islamic State fighters.
After that, the video cuts to the far longer processional scenes depicting rows of African migrants escorted through the desert and along the beach. For those who refuse Islam or jizya, the narrator says, “We owe nothing except the edge of the sword.”